mamamusings

elizabeth lane lawley's thoughts on technology, academia, family, and tangential topics

Friday, 12 November 2004

i suppose i should be flattered...

…that somebody cares enough to want to google bomb me!

Many thanks to Rob Page for (a) catching it, and (b) letting me know.

Update, Saturday 11/13
For those of you who are coming to the site after having received a comment on your blog with my URL in it, here’s an explanation.

I did not post the comments. They were generated by a kind of spamming software which is usually used to promote commercial web sites. In this case, the software is being put to use by someone (I don’t know who) that’s upset with either me or my writing, and is trying to accomplish two things. First, they want to associate my blog with the unpleasant descriptive term that’s being placed in the ‘name’ field on the comment, so that when people search for that term my site will be the first result. (That’s called “Googlebombing.”) Second, they want unsuspecting site owners to see the comments, assume I’m just another spammer, and add my site’s URL to their blacklist.

There’s not much I can do about it, except for enjoy the surge in traffic to my site, and hope that people will take the time to check out my site before reflexively blacklisting it.

Posted at 6:50 PM in: curmudgeonly | idle thoughts | technology
Trackbacks

TrackBack URL for this entry: http://mamamusings.net/mt/liztrack.cgi/895

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference i suppose i should be flattered...:

Blog Spam from Norlos.com on November 12, 2004 8:16 PM
Excerpt: It's a scourge. It's already made us unwelcomed at one web host. The software that runs good ol' Norlos is wonderfully flexible and open. But that's what makes us vulnerable. And spammers, being evil people, don't care whose fun they...
Whoever's responsible, cut it out. You make us look bad. from Three Years of Hell to Become the Devil on November 12, 2004 8:22 PM
Excerpt: Great. Not only do I have to put up with easily-Blacklistable spam suggesting that I need Cialis, Viagra, or more games of Texas Hold Em. (On the grounds, I guess, that after a four-hour erection nothing's better than a few...
Just to spite them... from FuzzyCo on November 12, 2004 8:29 PM
Excerpt: Someone is trying to use comment spam to (presumably) 1) associate Elizabeth Lane Lawley's web site with some unflattering terms...
Googlebomb Spam Attack from eclecticism on November 12, 2004 8:33 PM
Excerpt: Looks like someone's come up with a new, not-really-all-that-clever use for comment spam: using it to attempt to Googlebomb someone that they're ticked off at.
Google Bombing??? from Mom On the Alert on November 13, 2004 4:46 AM
Excerpt: You know what I said recently about never knowing what you might find around the next corner? I kept wondering about a random comment, that I didnít understand, made by somebody I didnít know. So I went exploring and I...
i'm not a google bomber from chumptastic dot org on November 13, 2004 11:31 AM
Excerpt: interesting. here's a new use for movabletype spam: IP Address: 142.32.208.234 Name: Whiny Communist Bitch Email Address: commie@mamamusings.net URL: http://www.mamamusings.net...
IT'S A WONDERFUL WORLD. from Mom On the Alert on November 14, 2004 1:33 AM
Excerpt: Oh the wonderful Spam Comments I get! Someone wants to give me money. Another wants to cure my hair loss. Of course, there have been those who think I might be interested in enlarging a piece of my anatomy that...
I need a break... from The Void on November 14, 2004 4:34 PM
Excerpt: ...From writing my paper. Therefore, I begin to write in...
Comment spam goes weird from Backup Brain on November 14, 2004 7:06 PM
Excerpt: We haven't had much if any problems with comment spam since upgrading to Movable Type 3 + MT-Blacklist (yay!), but I have to note that comment spam has gone from incredibly annoying to just plain weird. Example 1: Liz Lawley...
eLibel is still Libel from Webmink on November 14, 2004 8:18 PM
Excerpt: I've no idea who has started the libel campaign against Liz Lawley (because that's what it is, ignore the cyber-trappings), but whoever it is needs to realise that the 'e-' doesn't impress the courts. Oh, and anyone who's ever met Liz would laugh to he...
Social Software from frankpape.com on November 18, 2004 1:18 AM
Excerpt: Nearly ever since I can remember, the idea of communicating with other people over computer networks has fascinated me. I cut my technology teeth on movies like Wargames, and I recall thinking how cool it was that Matthew Broderick could...
Choosing to be a Comment Spammer Victim from Burningbird on November 18, 2004 2:49 PM
Excerpt: Liz Lawley was recently the recipient of a comment spamming gooble bombing attack. What happened is that someone placed comments in several weblogs, signed "Whiny Communist Bitch" and then included a link to Liz's site. There are two reasons for...
Comments
Comment from Chuck on November 12, 2004 6:55 PM (Permalink to Comment)

Actually they also are doing spam for you also. But safe to say they are not your fans since they leave the comment "I can't shut my pie hole" with each comment...

I was amused though. Congrads on pissing em off.


Comment from on November 12, 2004 7:02 PM (Permalink to Comment)

I got two of these from the following IP addresses:

62.39.252.123
210.212.140.25

I don't know if that info helps us figure out who set this up.


Comment from George on November 12, 2004 7:07 PM (Permalink to Comment)

That last comment was from me, btw. Two more just came through before I was able to add an entry to the blacklist.

Weird stuff.


Comment from Steve B. on November 12, 2004 7:13 PM (Permalink to Comment)

One IP posting the googlebomb to sites i monitor is in the domain tnmi-*.ip.telnetww.com. Another is in *.oceanic.net

Mail me if you want the exact ips...

I wonder if they know that more links to you will make you more googular and therefore a more important site...


Comment from Liz Lawley on November 12, 2004 7:13 PM (Permalink to Comment)

Thanks for the IPs. There's a third one that Rob sent me, so I suspect that this is someone who'll be hard to catch.


Comment from tunesmith on November 12, 2004 7:16 PM (Permalink to Comment)

damn... it made me reflexively add this url to my blacklist. I don't like that I'll have to pay more attention to the urls in my blacklist now.


Comment from Liz Lawley on November 12, 2004 7:17 PM (Permalink to Comment)

Ah. Suddenly it becomes clearer. They're trying to get me added to a master blacklist. :P

I'll mention it to Jay and ask him to make sure that it doesn't get into the central blacklist, at least.


Comment from scott partee on November 12, 2004 7:33 PM (Permalink to Comment)

I got some, too, just FYI. They say you're a "Whiney Communist Bitch". That sounds good to me!

Added you to my flickr contacts, btw.

Take care!


Comment from Pamela on November 12, 2004 7:38 PM (Permalink to Comment)

Hi there. My blog was also hit by your 'fan spammer.' Looks like someone doesn't like you. IP addresses I've seen are:

142.32.208.238
194.27.157.231


Comment from Michael Doss on November 12, 2004 7:39 PM (Permalink to Comment)

I just received two also. Good news, it got me to your site. Bad news, it might get you blacklisted. But since they're using different IP addresses (210.95.208.21 and 61.19.243.12 in my case, likely due to highjacked computers being used to send it), hopefully it won't universally blacklist you.


Comment from Jason on November 12, 2004 7:42 PM (Permalink to Comment)

Here's another IP:
129.187.126.171


Comment from norlos on November 12, 2004 7:47 PM (Permalink to Comment)

Here's another IP address for you: 200.201.178.58.

On the plus side, Mamamusings, you're getting some traffic. Doesn't change the nastiness of what's been done to you.


Comment from Kimmer on November 12, 2004 7:53 PM (Permalink to Comment)

I was wondering why you posted on something from over a year ago! I thought it was the old bitch I was posting about coming back to haunt me!! :) Spammers and assholes suck.


Comment from david on November 12, 2004 8:00 PM (Permalink to Comment)

I've been hit by 30 spams from "you" in the last 90 minutes...I'm glad to learn that it is NOT you, in fact. I hope the bastard/s responsible suffer some physical ailment that will prevent him/them from using a computer for many, many years. Some sort of advanced carpal-tunnel syndrome, or something.

Hang in there.


Comment from A. Rickey on November 12, 2004 8:05 PM (Permalink to Comment)

Oddly, I just got one of these as well. I'm glad I caught this, though, because I was about to MT-Blacklist it. This would be unfair if you ever decided--god knows why--to comment on my site.

You have my sympathy.


Comment from Carlo on November 12, 2004 8:17 PM (Permalink to Comment)

If I am unsure of the site I am about to add from my blacklist I check it out first - a quick visit here would obviously tell any intelligent person that you are not responsible for the crap being spread around - I've gotten spam comments from www.yahoo.com and www.msn.com before, which are obviously not from them.

"I can't shut my pie hole" is one of the comments? Sounds like someone has an issue with ignoring something they are not a fan of, or possibly an issue with being jealous of the attention you are receiving instead of them. Funny how some people only grow older and not wiser.


Comment from Eric Bostrom on November 12, 2004 8:49 PM (Permalink to Comment)

i too received one of these comments, it seems like it's more helping than hurting you though.


Comment from Kevin on November 12, 2004 8:57 PM (Permalink to Comment)

Hi there...I got one too. The IP address was 217.17.233.136 - Hope you track 'em down.


Comment from Alicia on November 12, 2004 9:08 PM (Permalink to Comment)

Well, you have a new reader thanks to the spam in my comments from your "friend". The piehole comment with the url was perplexing so I had to check the site out.

I'm just surprised even I got spammed as I have oh, I dunno, an average of 10 readers a day, lol.


Comment from David Weinberger on November 12, 2004 10:43 PM (Permalink to Comment)

I've gotten 4 from the whiny communist who can't shut her piehole:

207.80.14.5
80.18.225.2
142.32.208.232
220.228.32.1

Damn Intermenet!

: )


Comment from patrick on November 12, 2004 10:44 PM (Permalink to Comment)

Yep, I got one too on a post that had nothing to do with my liberal leanings. I usually rant like hell from a leftist perpective, but this was just a random personal post.

Oh, and the IP was 200.189.226.82


Comment from r@d@r on November 13, 2004 1:35 AM (Permalink to Comment)

greetings. your comment spammers just "badvertised" your web site to me - but after receiving ten of the "whiny communist etc" emails i was overcome with curiosity and had to drop by. i'm adding you to my blogrolls. very pleased to meet you!

how does it feel to fail, comment spammers? YEAH! CHOKE ON IT!!

sorry, i have a personal vendetta against those sort of people. :)

carry on ...
"r"


Comment from r@d@r on November 13, 2004 1:41 AM (Permalink to Comment)

p.s. -
here's what i harvested:
66.119.33.185
202.216.7.124
69.50.64.5
69.50.46.250


Comment from Mike on November 13, 2004 6:00 AM (Permalink to Comment)

Aye, my site was spammed too. Wow, what an asshole. Well, I hope it gets you more readers and not too much trouble.


Comment from Netwoman on November 13, 2004 10:14 AM (Permalink to Comment)

I am feeling left out...I didn't get spammed by the whiny communist bitch. hmm. Hang in there Liz :)


Comment from L] on November 13, 2004 12:19 PM (Permalink to Comment)

I got spammed too by the whiny communist bitch, lol. But I knew it looked odd when there wasn't all the usual spam paraphenalia in the message so thought I'd check out the link. It's scary to think that someone would do that to you.


Comment from Kaspper Jeppesen on November 13, 2004 1:09 PM (Permalink to Comment)

I have been reading your blog for a couple of months now, and even though I got pretty jealous when you wrote about going to acm cscw (haven't been to an acm conference since acm one), I can't seem to understand what you could possibly have said on your site that could get some moron that pissed off?


Comment from Dave Morgan on November 13, 2004 1:52 PM (Permalink to Comment)

I haven't gotten spammed, but I wouldn't be surprised if it was just a disgruntled student.

..those RIT types can really be a pain in the bum =P


Comment from Alexis Turner on November 13, 2004 3:17 PM (Permalink to Comment)

Good call putting the notice on your site, although I must admit I was immediately suspicious of the "spam" nature of the comment when I saw it was from a .net domain. Pretty unusual.

admin: raptor.slc.edu/blogs


Comment from Ted on November 13, 2004 3:32 PM (Permalink to Comment)

Using spam to badmouth someone - how childish. Even though I disagree strongly with a lot of your views, I wouldn't stoop that low. But at least you're getting lots of traffic and new readers. ;-)


Comment from Eli on November 13, 2004 6:51 PM (Permalink to Comment)

I got one of these as well and was about to Blacklist your site. But it looks like the spam may have worked in your favor as I have now added you to my favorites. :)


Comment from Ed on November 13, 2004 8:17 PM (Permalink to Comment)

This is utterly hilarious. This person who is so pissed at you is spending so much of their time on trying to comment spam and the sad thing is is that they are probably spending most of their time reading these replies. The sad thing is that they are feeling hurt inside and they are to scared and cowardly to show their true identity.

So sad... I pity them. I hope their pain goes away soon because it probably isn't fun feeling so worthless.


Comment from Liz Lawley on November 13, 2004 8:42 PM (Permalink to Comment)

Unfortunately, they probably aren't spending much time at all. There are programs out there that automate this process, including using proxy servers to spoof the originating IP addresses. All the culprit had to do was type the information in once.

However, it is true that it's having the opposite effect that they'd hoped for...I've got a bunch of new readers as a result. Which is a rather nice ironic twist.

And while my URL may end up on a couple of sites' blacklists, Jay Allen has promised me it won't make it onto the master MT blacklist. If I should run into a problem with it somewhere, I can always email the site admin and ask them to remove it--or just not include my blog URL, which is really not a big deal.


Comment from Justin on November 14, 2004 10:50 PM (Permalink to Comment)

At least in terms of making you the top entry from google, they did succeed. I thoroughly enjoy Expression Engine's CAPTCHAs, which seem to have done a perfect job (so far) of keeping comment spam off my blog. Unfortunately those using screen readers now have to become members to post comments (although this is more theoretical, considering the popularity, or lack thereof of my blog).


Comment from Ari on November 14, 2004 10:51 PM (Permalink to Comment)

i screen every comment so wont approve it, since you didn't write it, but "I just can't shut my pie hole." seems like a good thing to me! ;) keep whining!


Comment from Jack Vinson on November 15, 2004 11:29 PM (Permalink to Comment)

I am getting a bunch of comment spam that gives an unregistered URL (someone's name) and a short note. I don't get the point at all.


Comment from Dr.Acula on November 16, 2004 7:17 AM (Permalink to Comment)

Cool, that spammy thing hit my site! So yeah!


Comment from Cathy on November 18, 2004 2:27 PM (Permalink to Comment)

Jack, re: comment spam giving unregistered URLS - I've had a number of these myself and I think the point is that the URL seems innocuous, you check it out, find out it leads nowhere, and so don't delete/blacklist. A while later, the URL will be registered, and probably redirected to somewhere nastier.


Comment from Jack Vinson on November 29, 2004 2:15 PM (Permalink to Comment)

Another reason for comment spam: It sucks up bandwidth and eventually knocks out your website. I'm working on moving to a higher-bandwidth location, but until that happens I am stuck.


Post a comment

Thanks for signing in, . Now you can comment. (sign out)

(If you haven't left a comment here before, you may need to be approved by the site owner before your comment will appear. Until then, it won't appear on the entry. Thanks for waiting.)


Remember me?


Liz sipping melange at Cafe Central in Vienna